Juvan's Health Law Recap--February 25, 2007

Last week, I visited Orlando, Florida for the American Health Lawyers Association Long Term Care in the Law Conference.  This week's Health Law Recap will focus on a few themes and trends identified at the Conference. 

  • Shift in Long Term Care Reimbursement.  Leslie Norwalk, the Acting Administrator for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), focused on the increased pressure on the federal government resulting from the health financing crisis.  In response, federal reimbursement for long term care will shift in favor of home health agencies and away from skilled nursing facility care.
  • Employee Education About False Claims Act.  Many attorneys expressed to representatives of CMS that there continues to be substantial and noteworthy ambiguities in connection with the Deficit Reduction Act employee education requirements.  One attorney noted that the requirement applies to an entity that has less than 5 million dollars in Medicaid payments if the entity is affiliated with other entities that receive 5 million or more in such payments.  Representatives for CMS have promised that further clarification will follow shortly.
  • Plaintiffs' Lawyers Use Web Sites, E-Mail Addresses to Pierce the Corporate Veil.  There has been a strong trend for parent companies who acquire nursing home facilities to form separate subsidiaries to act as holding companies and operating companies for each nursing facility acquired.  One prominent defense attorney noted that plaintiffs' lawyers have begun to cite to web sites and e-mail addresses to build a case for veil piercing.  The lawyer cautioned that employees in each separate company should have different e-mail addresses. For example, if the parent company is named "Health Care Solutions, Inc.," one subsidiary is named "Brecksville Health Care Solutions, Inc."  and the other is "Madison Health Care Solutions, Inc.," the employees at the parent and both subs should not have their e-mail address as "employeename@healthcaresolutions.com."  Instead, the following e-mail addresses would help to show that the three entities are separate legal entities:

In addition, the attorney noted that legal counsel should review a company's web site and that the web site should clearly state that each facility is owned by a separate legal entity.

  • Medicaid Fraud Enforcement Is on the Rise.  Many representatives of the federal government emphasized that, in the upcoming years, the government will have increased budgets to implement Medicaid fraud controls and pursue Medicaid fraud investigations.  In the past, Medicaid has not received the same scrutiny as have other federal health care programs. 

 

Vioxx Case Ends in Merck's Favor

Merck & Co., Inc., vowing to fight individually each of the 24,000 suits against it alleging that the company failed to adequately warn consumers about the harmful side effects of Vioxx, an arthritis drug, and that Vioxx caused heart attacks, received a favorable verdict from a New Orleans jury today.  Vehemently opposing the claim that Vioxx caused Charles Mason's heart attack, attorneys for Merck argued that Merck complied with all reporting obligations and that other health factors were at the root of the cause of Mason's condition.  Phil Beck, an attorney for Merck, reflected on the victory, stating, "We thought the evidence showed clearly that first, Mr. Mason had not taken Vioxx for several days before his heart attack, and second, that there was no (blood) clot that could have come from Vioxx."

Thus far, Merck has successfully won seven out of eleven cases that have gone to trial, though in one the court ordered a new trial because additional evidence subsequently surfaced.  The Dean of Williams University School of Law David Logan has speculated that Merck will allow several more suits to go forward before deciding whether to settle with plaintiffs collectively.

News of the verdict hit before the NYSE closed.  Merck finished off the day at 44.15, up slightly, but still down from the 52 week high of 46.37.